If Hungryroot is the quick-and-easy option for allergy families, HelloFresh is its more “from scratch” cousin — the one who actually enjoys pulling out cutting boards and measuring spoons on a weeknight.
This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Our family recently tried HelloFresh to see how it stacked up for busy households with food allergies. We wanted to know: can it compete with allergy-friendly services like Hungryroot, or is it better suited for people without dietary restrictions?
Here’s what we found.
What Is HelloFresh, Anyway?
If you’ve ever seen those tidy green boxes in someone’s recycling bin, you’ve probably already spotted HelloFresh.
It’s one of the most popular meal delivery services in the U.S., and for good reason — it sends you a box each week packed with fresh ingredients and step-by-step recipe cards. You choose your meals ahead of time, and HelloFresh sends you almost everything you need to make them at home.
The twist? Unlike Hungryroot, most of HelloFresh’s ingredients come raw and unprocessed. You’ll do the seasoning, sautéing, and actual cooking yourself. It’s a more hands-on experience, but also one that can feel surprisingly satisfying if you enjoy spending time in the kitchen.
Pro #1: Fresh, Raw Ingredients
One thing HelloFresh absolutely nails is ingredient quality.
The produce is crisp, the proteins look fresh, and nothing arrives pre-cooked or overly packaged. This is a big shift from Hungryroot, which relies more on pre-prepped components like sous vide meats and ready-to-go sauces.
If you love the process of cooking — smelling fresh herbs, slicing veggies, and seasoning your food exactly the way you like — HelloFresh feels more like “real cooking.”
It’s not a heat-and-eat experience; it’s a hands-on one.
For my wife, that made dinners feel more creative and homemade — like we were actually preparing dinner, not just assembling it.
Pro #2: Simple, Easy-to-Follow Recipes
My wife especially appreciated how organized the recipe cards are.
HelloFresh lays out every step clearly, with visuals, cooking times, and ingredient lists that make even more complex dishes easy to follow. In that sense, it actually beats Hungryroot’s app-based directions, which can feel a little sparse.
The recipes also tend to work reliably — there’s very little guesswork. You don’t have to wonder if you’re doing something wrong halfway through cooking.
For families juggling multiple schedules, that kind of predictability is worth a lot. It’s one of HelloFresh’s biggest strengths, and definitely something we’ll reference again in our comparison article.
Pro #3: Food Discovery You Can Recreate Later
One thing we loved about HelloFresh was how reusable the recipes are.
Unlike Hungryroot, which uses many specialty ingredients that can be hard to find locally, HelloFresh meals rely on ingredients you can easily grab at your neighborhood grocery store.
That means if you find a recipe your family loves, you can make it again later without needing a subscription or tracking down obscure sauces online.
We’ve actually saved a few of the recipe cards to reuse — it’s a nice perk if you want to expand your family’s meal rotation or just discover new flavors.
For example, we tried a honey Dijon chicken with roasted carrots and lemony potatoes that quickly became a go-to weeknight meal. Now we make it from scratch whenever we want — no delivery required.
The Cons: Where HelloFresh Falls Short for Allergy Families
Here’s where things get complicated for anyone with food allergies or sensitivities.
While HelloFresh is transparent about allergens in their recipes, it does not let you set allergy filters or automatically remove meals containing your allergens.
According to their own support page (source), you’re expected to review each ingredient list and decide for yourself if it’s safe. That’s a lot of manual checking — especially when cross-contact warnings (“may contain”) aren’t always easy to spot.
In other words, HelloFresh isn’t built for allergy households.
You can swap ingredients on your own at home (for instance, using your own dairy-free cheese or gluten-free pasta), but the system itself doesn’t make those substitutions for you. Their FAQ even confirms there’s no official way to change or replace ingredients (source).
That’s fine if you’re avoiding an ingredient by choice — but if it’s an allergy, it’s a big downside.
Paying for Food You Can’t Use
This ties into another frustration: you’re often paying for ingredients you won’t eat.
If a meal contains an allergen (say, cheese or nuts), you’ll have to throw it out or swap it for something else you already have. But you’ve still paid for it.
Over time, that adds up — both in cost and in waste.
For families managing multiple food allergies, this can make HelloFresh feel like more hassle than help.
Who HelloFresh Is Great For
To be fair, HelloFresh isn’t pretending to be an allergy-friendly service.
It’s a great fit if you:
- Love cooking from scratch and enjoy the process.
- Don’t have picky eaters or food allergies to navigate.
- Don’t mind paying for the occasional ingredient you won’t use.
- Want to discover new recipes you can later recreate with grocery-store ingredients.
It’s not ideal if:
- You need built-in allergy filtering or substitution options.
- You’re short on time and want fast, ready-to-heat meals.
- You’re trying to minimize food waste or ingredient swaps.
Our Family Verdict
We liked HelloFresh — just not for allergy life.
The recipes are clear, the food quality is excellent, and it’s genuinely fun to cook together. My wife enjoyed the organization and ease of following the steps, and we’ve found a few recipes we’ll keep in our regular rotation.
But for our family — juggling allergies, kids, and busy schedules — HelloFresh just isn’t practical week to week. The lack of filtering or substitution options makes it too easy for allergens to slip through the cracks.
That said, we’d recommend it to families without allergies who want to get out of a dinner rut or learn new recipes that can be recreated from your local grocery store.
However, if you have food allergies, you may want to consider the allergy friendly alternative meal prep and delivery service Hungryroot (affiliate link).
Final Thoughts
HelloFresh delivers on its promise of fresh ingredients and approachable recipes. But for allergy families like ours, it still feels like a service designed for someone else.
It’s a bit like that one cookbook you love flipping through — full of inspiration and good ideas — but you still end up swapping half the ingredients before you can safely make the dish.
Up Next: The Showdown (HelloFresh vs. Hungryroot)
Now that we’ve tested both, our next post will compare Hungryroot vs. HelloFresh head-to-head — including which one is faster, safer for allergies, and better for real family life.
If you’ve tried either service (or both!), I’d love to hear what your experience was like — especially if you’re managing food allergies in your home.
Until then, here’s to safe, delicious, and drama-free dinners — one recipe card at a time.